@Theburgermanorisnotaburgerman I have the exact same opinion, and people try to “correct” me, when I actually know that it is two completely different places.
Both are set in different times of day, they have different areas in the map, Malik is specified as a Winter Holiday surfer while Clementine used to be specified as a North Pole surfer.
SYBO never confirmed nor denied the theory, leading to fans just making unrealistic assumptions. It is two different things.